Alternatives to Peanut Butter Spreads

Sort by: Sugar Sodium Protein Calories

How alternatives were chosen: Based on products in the same category that have nutrition facts, ordered by sugars, lowest first (values per 100 g; ties by name). The list does not drop products with a higher value than the original; the differences are shown next to each product · check the label.

Original product Peanut Butter Spreads REESE'S
552Calories 8.7Protein 32.5Fat —Sat. fat —Sugars

120 alternatives, ordered by sugars, lowest first

  1. NuttZo LLC Organic Peanut Pro Crunchy +24 calories+12.5 g protein
    576Calories 21.2Protein 51.5Fat 7.6Sat. fat 3.0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  2. NuttZo LLC Organic Peanut Pro Smooth +24 calories+12.5 g protein
    576Calories 21.2Protein 51.5Fat 7.6Sat. fat 3.0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  3. Wakefern Food Corporation Organic, Unsalted Sunflower Seed Butter, Unsalted +54 calories+9.5 g protein
    606Calories 18.2Protein 57.6Fat 4.5Sat. fat 3.0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  4. Wakefern Food Corporation Organic, Unsalted Sunflower Seed Butter, Unsalted +54 calories+9.5 g protein
    606Calories 18.2Protein 57.6Fat 4.5Sat. fat 3.0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  5. Wakefern Food Corporation Organic, Unsalted Sunflower Seed Butter, Unsalted +54 calories+9.5 g protein
    606Calories 18.2Protein 57.6Fat 4.5Sat. fat 3.0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  6. East Wind Nut Butters Peanut Butter +54 calories+15.5 g protein
    606Calories 24.2Protein 48.5Fat 9.1Sat. fat 3.0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  7. NuttZo LLC Power Fuel Crunchy 7 Nut & Seed Butter, Power Fuel Crunchy −7 calories+9.5 g protein
    545Calories 18.2Protein 45.5Fat 6.1Sat. fat 3.0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  8. NuttZo LLC Power Fuel Crunchy 7 Nut & Seed Butter, Power Fuel Crunchy −7 calories+9.5 g protein
    545Calories 18.2Protein 45.5Fat 6.1Sat. fat 3.0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  9. NuttZo LLC Power Fuel Smooth 7 Nut & Seed Butter, Power Fuel Smooth −7 calories+9.5 g protein
    545Calories 18.2Protein 45.5Fat 6.1Sat. fat 3.0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  10. NuttZo LLC Power Fuel Smooth 7 Nut & Seed Butter, Power Fuel Smooth −7 calories+9.5 g protein
    545Calories 18.2Protein 45.5Fat 6.1Sat. fat 3.0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  11. 88 acres foods, inc Roasted No Added Sugar Watermelon Seed Butter, Roasted +24 calories+18.6 g protein
    576Calories 27.3Protein 51.5Fat 9.1Sat. fat 3.0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  12. 88 acres foods, inc Roasted Watermelon Seed Butter, Roasted Watermelon +24 calories+18.6 g protein
    576Calories 27.3Protein 51.5Fat 9.1Sat. fat 3.0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  13. New Seasons Market, LLC Sunflower Butter +54 calories+9.5 g protein
    606Calories 18.2Protein 51.5Fat 6.1Sat. fat 3.0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  14. Way Out West Pictures INC Toaster Chunky +24 calories+12.5 g protein
    576Calories 21.2Protein 48.5Fat 4.5Sat. fat 3.0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  15. Way Out West Pictures INC Truly Raw Chunky +24 calories+12.5 g protein
    576Calories 21.2Protein 48.5Fat 4.5Sat. fat 3.0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  16. The J.M. Smucker Company 100% Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter, Crunchy +10 calories+16.3 g protein
    562Calories 25Protein 50Fat 6.2Sat. fat 3.1Sugars Compare Alternatives
  17. Supreme Specialty Foods 5 Seed Crunchy Butter, 5 Seed Crunchy +73 calories+16.3 g protein
    625Calories 25Protein 53.1Fat 6.2Sat. fat 3.1Sugars Compare Alternatives
  18. The J.M. Smucker Company Adams, 100% Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter +73 calories+16.3 g protein
    625Calories 25Protein 50Fat 7.8Sat. fat 3.1Sugars Compare Alternatives
  19. The J.M. Smucker Company Adams, Organic Peanut Butter, Creamy +104 calories+16.3 g protein
    656Calories 25Protein 50Fat 7.8Sat. fat 3.1Sugars Compare Alternatives
  20. The J.M. Smucker Company Adams, Peanut Butter +73 calories+16.3 g protein
    625Calories 25Protein 50Fat 7.8Sat. fat 3.1Sugars Compare Alternatives
  21. The J.M. Smucker Company Adams, Peanut Butter, Creamy +73 calories+16.3 g protein
    625Calories 25Protein 50Fat 7.8Sat. fat 3.1Sugars Compare Alternatives
  22. Horizon Marketing Inc. Almond Butter −21 calories+13.2 g protein
    531Calories 21.9Protein 46.9Fat 3.1Sat. fat 3.1Sugars Compare Alternatives
  23. Lake Ventures LLC Almond Butter Creamy, Almond Butter +42 calories+13.2 g protein
    594Calories 21.9Protein 50Fat 3.1Sat. fat 3.1Sugars Compare Alternatives
  24. Wegmans Food Markets, Inc. Almond Butter, Almond +136 calories+10.1 g protein
    688Calories 18.8Protein 59.4Fat 7.8Sat. fat 3.1Sugars Compare Alternatives

Back to Peanut Butter Spreads

Note: This site presents label data from USDA FoodData Central for general information. It is not medical advice. Check the package label; formulations change.