Alternatives to Black Diamond, Premium Cheddar Cheese, Sharp Cheddar, Sharp Cheddar

Sort by: Sugar Sodium Protein Calories

How alternatives were chosen: Based on products in the same category that have nutrition facts, ordered by sugars, lowest first (values per 100 g; ties by name). The list does not drop products with a higher value than the original; the differences are shown next to each product · check the label.

Original product Black Diamond, Premium Cheddar Cheese, Sharp Cheddar, Sharp Cheddar Lactalis American Group, Inc.
429Calories 25Protein 35.7Fat 21.4Sat. fat 0Sugars

120 alternatives, ordered by sugars, lowest first

  1. Nisco Foods, LLC 3 Cheese Blend Parmesan Romano Asiago +71 calories+15 g protein−1.4 g sat. fat
    500Calories 40Protein 40Fat 20Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  2. Kingston Marketing Co 3 Cheese Blend Parmesan, Romano & Asiago Shredded Cheese, 3 Cheese Blend −36 calories+3.6 g protein
    393Calories 28.6Protein 32.1Fat 21.4Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  3. Armanino Foods Of Distinction 3 Cheese Blend Romano, Parmesan, Asiago 100% Grated Cheese, 3 Cheese Blend +51 calories+15 g protein+2.6 g sat. fat
    480Calories 40Protein 32Fat 24Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  4. Price Chopper Supermarkets 3 Cheese Blend, Grated Cheese, Parmesan, Romano, Asiago −29 calories+15 g protein−1.4 g sat. fat
    400Calories 40Protein 30Fat 20Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  5. Sargento Foods Inc 3 Cheese Creamy Jack Slices, 3 Cheese Creamy Jack −40 calories−2.8 g protein−2.0 g sat. fat
    389Calories 22.2Protein 27.8Fat 19.4Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  6. Cooperative Regions of Organic Producer Pools 3 Cheese Italian A Blend Of Low Moisture Part Skim Mozzarella, Provolone & Sharp Cheddar Thick Cut Off The Block Cheeses, 3 Cheese Italian −108 calories−5.4 g sat. fat
    321Calories 25Protein 25Fat 16.1Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  7. Cooperative Regions of Organic Producer Pools 3 Cheese Mexican A Blend Of Sharp Cheddar, Colby & Monterey Jack Cheeses, 3 Cheese Mexican −36 calories−3.6 g protein−3.6 g sat. fat
    393Calories 21.4Protein 32.1Fat 17.9Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  8. Redwood Hill Farm & Creamery, LLC 3 Cheese Mexican Lactose Free A Blend Of Cheddar, Monterey Jack & Colby Shredded Cheeses, 3 Cheese Mexican −36 calories
    393Calories 25Protein 32.1Fat 21.4Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  9. Milton G. Waldbaum Company 3 Cheese Mexican Style Blend Of Monterey Jack Cheese With Jalapeno Peppers, Muenster Cheese & Cheddar Cheese, 3 Cheese Mexican Style Blend −36 calories−3.6 g protein−3.6 g sat. fat
    393Calories 21.4Protein 28.6Fat 17.9Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  10. Forager Project, LLC 3 Cheeze Blend Queso Fresco, Monterey Jack, Cheddar Organic Vegan & Dairy-Free Cultured Cheese Alternative From Our Cashewmilk Yogurt, 3 Cheeze Blend −179 calories−7.1 g sat. fat
    250Calories —Protein 17.9Fat 14.3Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  11. Emmi Roth USA, Inc. 3 Chile Pepper Gouda −72 calories−3.6 g sat. fat
    357Calories 25Protein 28.6Fat 17.9Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  12. Boar's Head Provision Co., Inc. 3 Pepper Bold Spicy Colby Jack Cheese, 3 Pepper −72 calories−3.6 g protein−3.6 g sat. fat
    357Calories 21.4Protein 28.6Fat 17.9Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  13. Milton G. Waldbaum Company 3 Pepper Cheese A Blend Of Monterey Jack Cheese With Jalapeo & Habanero Peppers & Cheddar Cheese With Chipotle Peppers, 3 Pepper Cheese −36 calories−3.6 g protein−3.6 g sat. fat
    393Calories 21.4Protein 28.6Fat 17.9Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  14. Darigold, Inc. 3 Pepper Jack A Blend Of Jalapeno, Habanero, And Ghost Peppers Thin Sliced Cheese, 3 Pepper Jack −61 calories−3.9 g protein−5.6 g sat. fat
    368Calories 21.1Protein 26.3Fat 15.8Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  15. Milton G. Waldbaum Company 3 Pepper Natural Cheese, 3 Pepper −36 calories−3.6 g protein−3.6 g sat. fat
    393Calories 21.4Protein 32.1Fat 17.9Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  16. Big Y Foods, Inc. 3 State Cheddar Cheese Blend Shredded From New York Sharp, Wisconsin Sharp & Vermont Sharp Cheddar Cheeses, 3 State Cheddar −36 calories−3.6 g protein−3.6 g sat. fat
    393Calories 21.4Protein 32.1Fat 17.9Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  17. Tops Markets, LLC 3 State Sharp Cheddar Cheese Blend Vermont, Wisconsin, And New York Cheddar Fancy Shredded Cheeses, 3 State Sharp Cheddar Cheese Blend −36 calories
    393Calories 25Protein 32.1Fat 21.4Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  18. Meijer, Inc. 3 State Sharp Cheddar Wisconsin, New York & Vermont Shredded Cheeses, 3 State Sharp Cheddar −36 calories
    393Calories 25Protein 32.1Fat 21.4Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  19. WI Aging & Grading Cheese, Inc. 3 Year Aged Wisconsin Cheddar Cheese, 3 Year Aged Wisconsin Cheddar
    429Calories 25Protein 35.7Fat 21.4Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  20. 33% Lower Fat & 36% Lower Sodium American Cheese −108 calories−5.4 g sat. fat
    321Calories 25Protein 21.4Fat 16.1Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  21. 33% Lower Fat & 36% Lower Sodium American Cheese −108 calories−5.4 g sat. fat
    321Calories 25Protein 21.4Fat 16.1Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  22. Whole Foods Market, Inc. 365 Everyday Value, Delicious Natural Cheese, Emmentaler, Emmentaler −72 calories+3.6 g protein
    357Calories 28.6Protein 28.6Fat 21.4Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  23. Whole Foods Market, Inc. 365 Everyday Value, White Cheddar Thin-Sauced Cheese, Mild, Mild −38 calories+1.1 g protein−1.9 g sat. fat
    391Calories 26.1Protein 34.8Fat 19.6Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  24. Meijer, Inc. 4 Alarm Cheese Dip, 4 Alarm −18.3 g protein−8.1 g sat. fat
    —Calories 6.7Protein 26.7Fat 13.3Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives

Back to Black Diamond, Premium Cheddar Cheese, Sharp Cheddar, Sharp Cheddar

Note: This site presents label data from USDA FoodData Central for general information. It is not medical advice. Check the package label; formulations change.