Alternatives to Peanut Butter

How alternatives were chosen: Based on products in the same category that have nutrition facts, ordered by sugars, lowest first (values per 100 g; ties by name). The list does not drop products with a higher value than the original; the differences are shown next to each product · check the label.

120 alternatives, ordered by sugars, lowest first

25. 25
    Kenover Marketing Corp. Black Licorice Sugar Free Hard Candy, Black Licorice −338 calories−14.3 g protein−14.3 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    233Calories 0Protein 0Fat 0Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
26. 26
    American Licorice Company Black Licorice Sugar Free Twists, Black Licorice −238 calories−11.0 g protein−14.3 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    333Calories 3.3Protein 0Fat 0Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
27. 27
    Dr. John's Candies Blue Raspberry Cherry Grape Lemon Lime & Orange Flavored Sugar Free Classic Fruit Hard Candy, Blue Raspberry Cherry Grape Lemon Lime & Orange −377 calories−14.3 g protein−14.3 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    194Calories 0Protein 0Fat 0Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
28. 28
    Russell Stover Candies Inc. Blueberry Fruit Flavored Centers Enrobed In Smooth Dark Chocolate Sugar Free Bites, Blueberry −226 calories−10.8 g protein−0.5 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    345Calories 3.5Protein 20.7Fat 13.8Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
29. 29
    Russell Stover Candies Inc. Break-It Rabbit Solid Chocolate Candy −106 calories−7.3 g protein+6.6 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    465Calories 7.0Protein 34.9Fat 20.9Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
30. 30
    Perfetti Van Melle USA Inc. Bubble Fresh Cotton Candy Sugarfree Gum, Bubble Fresh Cotton Candy −321 calories−14.3 g protein−38.1 g sugars
    250Calories 0Protein 0Fat —Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
31. 31
    Brown & Haley Buttercrunch Toffee With Almonds −127 calories−8.7 g protein+2.4 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    444Calories 5.6Protein 38.9Fat 16.7Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
32. 32
    Ahold USA, Inc. Butterscotch Buttons Hard Candy −290 calories−14.3 g protein−14.3 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    281Calories 0Protein 0Fat 0Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
33. 33
    Topco Associates, Inc. Butterscotch Buttons Sugar Free Candies, Butterscotch Buttons −259 calories−14.3 g protein−14.3 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    312Calories 0Protein 0Fat 0Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
34. 34
    Walgreens Co. Butterscotch Discs −277 calories−14.3 g protein−14.3 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    294Calories 0Protein 0Fat 0Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
35. 35
    Rite Aid Corporation Butterscotch Discs −371 calories−14.3 g protein−14.3 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    200Calories 0Protein 0Fat 0Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
36. 36
    Weis Markets, Inc. Butterscotch Discs Candy, Butterscotch Discs −290 calories−14.3 g protein−38.1 g sugars
    281Calories 0Protein 0Fat —Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
37. 37
    Dr. John's Candies Butterscotch, Chocolate Swirl, Cafe Caramel, & Vanilla Swirl Flavored Caramel Lovers Collection, Butterscotch, Chocolate Swirl, Cafe Caramel, & Vanilla Swirl −218 calories−8.4 g protein−11.3 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    353Calories 5.9Protein 5.9Fat 2.9Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
38. 38
    Cookies United, LLC Cakebites Jurassic Raptor Blue, 2 Oz, 4 Count, Blue Berry; Apple −97 calories−10.8 g protein+1.5 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    474Calories 3.5Protein 26.3Fat 15.8Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
39. 39
    Ice Chips Candy Candy Cane −321 calories−14.3 g protein−38.1 g sugars
    250Calories 0Protein 0Fat —Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
40. 40
    Ice Chips Candy Candy, Cinnamon −321 calories−14.3 g protein−38.1 g sugars
    250Calories 0Protein 0Fat —Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
41. 41
    Ice Chips Candy Candy, Lemon −321 calories−14.3 g protein−38.1 g sugars
    250Calories 0Protein 0Fat —Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
42. 42
    Atkins Nutritionals, Inc. Candy, Peanut Butter Cups −100 calories−8.4 g protein+6.3 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    471Calories 5.9Protein 38.2Fat 20.6Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
43. 43
    Ice Chips Candy Candy, Real Peppermint −321 calories−14.3 g protein−38.1 g sugars
    250Calories 0Protein 0Fat —Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
44. 44
    Ice Chips Candy Candy, Root Beer Float −321 calories−14.3 g protein−38.1 g sugars
    250Calories 0Protein 0Fat —Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
45. 45
    Tops Markets, LLC Candy, Sugar Free Gummi Bears −321 calories−9.3 g protein−14.3 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    250Calories 5Protein 0Fat 0Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
46. 46
    Packom, LLC. Candy, Tangerine −321 calories−14.3 g protein−38.1 g sugars
    250Calories 0Protein 0Fat —Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
47. 47
    Storck USA LP Caramel Chocolate Flavored Hard Candies, Caramel Chocolate −321 calories−14.3 g protein−8.0 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    250Calories 0Protein 9.4Fat 6.2Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
48. 48
    Storck USA LP Caramel Coffee Hard Candies −321 calories−14.3 g protein−11.2 g sat. fat−38.1 g sugars
    250Calories 0Protein 6.2Fat 3.1Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives

Back to Peanut Butter