Alternatives to Cookie Dough

Sort by: Sugar Sodium Protein Calories

How alternatives were chosen: Based on products in the same category that have nutrition facts, ordered by sugars, lowest first (values per 100 g; ties by name). The list does not drop products with a higher value than the original; the differences are shown next to each product · check the label.

Original product Cookie Dough Providence Products, LLC
757Calories 39.3Protein 53.6Fat 14.3Sat. fat 3.6Sugars

120 alternatives, ordered by sugars, lowest first

  1. Old Home Foods Inc 100% All Natural Creamy Peanut Butter −163 calories−14.3 g protein−8.0 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    594Calories 25Protein 50Fat 6.2Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  2. Old Home Foods Inc 100% All Natural Spread, Crunchy Peanut Butter −163 calories−14.3 g protein−8.0 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    594Calories 25Protein 50Fat 6.2Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  3. Soofer Co. Inc. 100% Pure Sesame Tahini −114 calories−14.3 g protein−5.4 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    643Calories 25Protein 53.6Fat 8.9Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  4. Ross Products Division Abbott, Eas, Advantedge Carb Control Shakes, Cafe Caramel, Cafe Caramel −724 calories−34.1 g protein−14.1 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    33Calories 5.2Protein 0.8Fat 0.1Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  5. Kowalski Companies Inc. All Natural, Peanut Butter −7 calories−10.7 g protein−3.6 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    750Calories 28.6Protein 53.6Fat 10.7Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  6. Orange Music, Inc. Almond Butter −226 calories−17.4 g protein−11.2 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    531Calories 21.9Protein 46.9Fat 3.1Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  7. Dalex Co. Aunt Renee's Roasted Organic Pecan Butter, Aunt Renee's Roasted −43 calories−32.1 g protein−7.1 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    714Calories 7.1Protein 64.3Fat 7.1Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  8. Jordan Eyewear, Inc. Big Tree Farms, Raw Cacao Butter +143 calories−39.3 g protein+50.0 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    900Calories 0Protein 100Fat 64.3Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  9. Ahold USA, Inc. Cashew Butter −157 calories−22.6 g protein−4.3 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    600Calories 16.7Protein 53.3Fat 10Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  10. Tsunami Recordings Cashew Butter −163 calories−20.5 g protein−4.9 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    594Calories 18.8Protein 50Fat 9.4Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  11. Jo-Lee Food Products, Inc. Cashew Butter −163 calories−23.7 g protein−4.9 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    594Calories 15.6Protein 50Fat 9.4Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  12. PANOS Brands LLC Chocolate Peanut Spread, Chocolate Peanut −757 calories−39.3 g protein−3.6 g sugars
    0Calories 0Protein 0Fat —Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  13. Old Home Foods Inc Creamy Peanut Butter −163 calories−14.3 g protein−8.0 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    594Calories 25Protein 50Fat 6.2Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  14. Kowalski Companies Inc. Creamy Peanut Butter −7 calories−10.7 g protein−3.6 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    750Calories 28.6Protein 53.6Fat 10.7Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  15. Once Again Nut Butter Collective, Inc. Creamy Unsweetened Salt Free Tahini, Creamy Unsweetened −57 calories−19.3 g protein−4.3 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    700Calories 20Protein 63.3Fat 10Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  16. Once Again Nut Butter Collective, Inc. Creamy Unsweetened Salt Free Tahini, Creamy Unsweetened −57 calories−19.3 g protein−4.3 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    700Calories 20Protein 63.3Fat 10Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  17. Once Again Nut Butter Collective, Inc. Creamy Unsweetened Salt Free Tahini, Creamy Unsweetened −57 calories−19.3 g protein−4.3 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    700Calories 20Protein 63.3Fat 10Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  18. Once Again Nut Butter Collective, Inc. Creamy Unsweetened Salt Free Tahini, Creamy Unsweetened −57 calories−19.3 g protein−4.3 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    700Calories 20Protein 63.3Fat 10Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  19. Once Again Nut Butter Collective, Inc. Creamy Unsweetened Tahini, Creamy Unsweetened −57 calories−19.3 g protein−4.3 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    700Calories 20Protein 63.3Fat 10Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  20. Old Home Foods Inc Crunchy Peanut Butter −163 calories−14.3 g protein−8.0 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    594Calories 25Protein 50Fat 6.2Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  21. Faith Walk Designs, Inc. Dastony, Almond Butter −125 calories−14.3 g protein−7.1 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    632Calories 25Protein 60.7Fat 7.1Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  22. Faith Walk Designs, Inc. Dastony, Organic Sprouted Almond Butter −125 calories−14.3 g protein−7.1 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    632Calories 25Protein 60.7Fat 7.1Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  23. Faith Walk Designs, Inc. Dastony, Organic Sprouted Sunflower Seed Butter −178 calories−17.9 g protein−10.7 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    579Calories 21.4Protein 46.4Fat 3.6Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
  24. Georgia Peach Products, Inc. Dierbergs Markets, Peanut Butter −132 calories−11.2 g protein−4.9 g sat. fat−3.6 g sugars
    625Calories 28.1Protein 46.9Fat 9.4Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives

Back to Cookie Dough

Note: This site presents label data from USDA FoodData Central for general information. It is not medical advice. Check the package label; formulations change.